Voitures neuves au Maroc : un premier trimestre marqué par une hausse de 35 % des ventes    Groupe Akdital : des résultats solides en 2024 et des objectifs clairs pour l'avenir    Air Arabia Maroc connecte Nador à Murcie en mai prochain    Dakhla: l'AMCI et Attijariwafa bank lancent un cycle de formation à l'entreprenariat    La météo pour ce samedi 5 avril    Revue de presse de ce samedi 5 avril 2025    Foot féminin U17: Le Maroc accrochée par le Kenya    Le PP critique le transfert de la gestion de l'espace aérien du Sahara au Maroc : un danger pour la souveraineté espagnole ?"    Présentation à Paris du climat des affaires et des perspectives d'investissement au Maroc    L'Etat décrète l'expropriation d'un terrain dans le Sud pour l'édification d'une installation permanente des Forces armées royales    Projet d'aménagement stratégique à Dakhla : l'Etat acquiert un terrain de près de 7 000 m2 à Imlili    Maroc : l'Etat procède à l'expropriation de plus de 400 parcelles pour des projets d'envergure nationale    Casablanca : Les «églises informelles» dans le viseur du PJD    Guerre tarifaire: Trump fustige les représailles de la Chine, insiste que sa politique sera maintenue    Sahara : le chef de la diplomatie espagnole dénonce «l'irresponsabilité» de ceux qui s'agrippent à des principes supposés de l'autodétermination pour figer le conflit    Olympiades EHTP : un événement grandiose célébrant le sport, l'art et la culture à l'école Hassania des travaux publics    Amical : les lionnes de l'Atlas battent la Tunisie 3-1    Casablanca accueille la réunion annuelle du conseil international de la volaille    Le Maroc, un partenaire clé de l'OTAN dans le voisinage sud    Sobrevivir y reinventarse: Cuando los marroquíes cocinaban langostas en tiempos de crisis    Después de los reveses sufridos, el Polisario cambia a su jefe de diplomacia    Affaire Bennis-Alj-Slaoui : Libération provisoire des mis en cause    «Ecoles pionnières»: Le ministère s'allie à l'ONDH pour le processus de labellisation    Marrakech : un nouveau visage pour la Place Jamaâ El Fna    Science : le Cercle psychanalytique décrypte "Les structures psychiques" de Vannier (VIDEO)    Musique : Sean Paul et Craig David au Timeless Festival de Casablanca    CAN U17: La Tunisie et le Sénégal se neutralisent    Rassemblement islamiste contenu à Alger : la solidarité avec Gaza confrontée à l'interdiction du régime des manifestations    Trafic d'un bébé marocain en Italie : les suspects poursuivis en détention    Espagne: Trois morts dans l'effondrement d'un hangar agricole provoqué par la tempête    CAF U17: La Gambie se relance, la Somalie s'enfonce !    Football pour amputés : Des responsables marocains nommés au sein de la Fédération Internationale de Football de la discipline    L'Humeur : Val Kilmer dans les bras de Jim Morrison    El Jadida : Ces agrès, qui subliment désormais le cadre du front de mer !    Amine Radi ou « Le caméléon de l'humour »    Royal Air Maroc et Mauritania Airlines scellent un partenariat stratégique    Classement futsal : 6e chez les hommes, le Maroc progresse de 18 places chez les femmes    PSG : Achraf Hakimi explique comment Luis Enrique l'a fait progresser    Sahara : Avant de se rendre chez le Polisario, De Mistura était à Laayoune    Le 30e SIEL rend un hommage posthume à l'écrivain Driss Chraïbi    La visite du président du Sénat chilien à Laâyoune incarne un soutien parlementaire renouvelé à l'intégrité territoriale du Maroc    Coup d'envoi à Rabat du 20ème Rallye national du corps diplomatique    Marche massive attendue à Paris en soutien à l'indépendance de la République kabyle    Mohamed Essaadi: "La taxation américaine, un véritable tsunami économique"    L'avenir du commerce international en lien avec l'emploi au menu d'un entretien de Younes Sekkouri avec la DG de l'OMC    Un petit bout du Maroc à Paris : le soleil s'invite place Saint-Michel    Le Royaume-Uni discute avec le Maroc l'autonomie au Sahara    Maroc : L'USFP condamne une décision du président Erdogan    







Merci d'avoir signalé!
Cette image sera automatiquement bloquée après qu'elle soit signalée par plusieurs personnes.



Casablanca Court : Thousands of recovery cases handled at once without summoning debtors
Publié dans Yabiladi le 06 - 03 - 2020

At the Casablanca First Instance Court, thousands of recovery cases are tried at the first hearing, unbeknownst to consumers and their defense. In fact, court summons are sent to mistaken addresses. The practices that have been around since 2017 involve the same judges, lawyers, bailiffs, clerics and creditors. The Moroccan Federation of Consumer Rights has also been contacted.
It is 11 a.m. on December 12, 2019 at the Casablanca Civil Court of First Instance. The sixth chamber in charge of commercial affairs has dealt with 1,077 files at once. A record performance for the Moroccan justice and perhaps even globally.
These are mainly claims for payment filed by banks, insurance companies, credit companies, telecommunications companies and other large firms. From the first hearing, the verdicts on 1,000 of these cases are deemed to be in accordance with the request of the lawyer. Almost 871 of these cases concern banking, credit institutions, more than a hundred are related to the Moroccan subsidiaries of French insurance companies, and nearly 130 are for other companies, among others.
Seven days later, in the same room, the same judge examined 459 files. They were all dealt with in one session and their verdicts were delivered on the same morning.
In other hearings and since 2017, the files examined have approached or exceeded 1,000 suddenly. As a result, 81,375 files brought before the court from January 2017 to February 2020 were affected by these practices. The same judges (between 4 and 6 depending on the year), same lawyers (6 in total) and the same complainant companies (10) return with more than a hundred files per hearing each.
«Unfair» practices?
Thus, ten judges in charge of commercial affairs at the Casablanca Court of First Instance work on the files, but only one of them has singlehandedly examined more than half of them. He is followed by three of his fellow judges, who deal with the remaining cases. In 2017 alone, the judge who worked on the most trials had handled thousands of files : on January 18, he examined 500, on February 18 he dealt with 500, March 8, 317; 747 cases were examined on April 26, 2017 and several hundred others during the following months.
On February 28, 2018, he took care of 1,170 files at once; on March 7, 1,258 files were examined; and on the 14th of the same month, 1,207 cases were dealt with.
The other judges have an efficiency more or less identical to the aforementioned one: between 800 and 1,200 cases handled by hearing.
These abnormally high figures, the recurrence of the same plaintiff companies, the same lawyers and the same judges were reported to Yabiladi by victims who describe these practices as «false trials», pointing to several other anomalies.
Suits filed in Casablanca while debtors reside in other cities
The court of first instance can only deal with recovery cases with claims that are less than 20,000 dirhams in value according to the law. However, several cases consulted by Yabiladi greatly exceed this amount. This same court even orders urban or rural municipalities to pay while the actions fall under the administrative courts and the addresses refer to offices in Casablanca.
These practices surprised those notified of the convictions pronounced against them, even though they had never received summons to attend hearings. «These thousands of files whose court references follow each other have been judged in batches» and almost all of the accused could not hire a lawyer, «which indicates that summons were not made on a regular nor legal» basis, one of the concerned alleged victims told Yabiladi.
However, the hearings' summons, consulted by Yabiladi, mostly feature wrong addresses. Some of them were even located in other cities and were supposed to have been dealt with locally. For example, some companies actually domiciled in Tiznit or Taza have been assigned with Casablanca addresses. The stamp of the same bailiff clerk is found in many of these «false summons».
Morover, the names of those summoned are often entered in French only, while the documents published in court must be transcribed in Arabic. This is also the case for the minutes of most hearings. Indeed, these documents do not seem to have been handwritten in court, but seized by computer, which may have been done in order to automate the processing of hundreds of files via direct mail (also known as junk mail or admail).
Criminal liability offenses
All of these irregularities may represent a violation of several laws. One of them is the principle of fair trial, recognized in article 120 of the Constitution, stating that «everyone has the right to a fair trial and to a judgment rendered within a reasonable time. The rights of the defense are guaranteed before all courts». This is not the case when a matter is judged at the first hearing without the presence of the defense.
Furthermore, these practices violate article 111 of law n° 31.08 enacting consumer protection measures. In fact, the first paragraph of this text provides that «claims for payment must be brought before the court that covers the home or place of residence of the borrower».
Also, article 39 of the Code of Civil Procedure specifies the rules for convening a hearing, the writing of which is signed by the authority or the agent and not by the clerk. «Even though the judge should check that the request, the fold and the address appear in the statement, the latter does not check and pronounce the conviction», said the lawyer of one of the alleged victims.
These practices question the responsibility of the parties dealing with these trials and the plaintiff companies.
«The addresses contained in the envelopes constitute forgery in writing and their use is repressed by the provisions of the Penal Code», denounces the lawyer of one of the alleged victims while denouncing what he referred to as an act akin to «swindle». If the 81,375 convicted parties since January 1, 2017 file a complaint, this may lead to one of the biggest legal scandals in the Kingdom.


Cliquez ici pour lire l'article depuis sa source.